You’ve heard that politics is dirty. Well, you ain’t seen nothin’ yet. The following article is about some strange goings on at Oregon State University. Three PhD students, all homeschooled by their father, may be denied their degree, not because of their work but because of their father’s political views. The following article was written by Art Robinson, the father of Joshua, Bethany, and Matthew. For first-hand updates, go to http://www.OregonStateOutrage.com/ We’ll keep you posted on future developments.
— Gary DeMar
In 2006, when Joshua and Bethany Robinson, children of Oregon Congressional candidate Art Robinson, decided to earn PhD degrees, the family’s long interest in nuclear energy and the proximity of Oregon State University’s outstanding graduate program in nuclear engineering led to a natural choice.
The Robinson twins, Joshua and Bethany, immediately thrived at OSU. With GPAs of 3.49 and 3.89, high ability, and a strong work ethic, their work was greatly respected, and their futures seemed bright. In 2009, they were joined by their younger brother Matthew, who also entered the PhD program in nuclear engineering. Matthew turned down an offer of $57,000 per year from the MIT graduate school in preference for OSU.
Bethany was especially unusual. A brilliant and hardworking young woman, she would become one of the very few female PhD students in nuclear engineering in the United States.
The PhD degree is based upon classroom performance, examination performance, and research work—combined in an individual with a high work ethic. In all of these categories, the Robinson students excelled, so their future was bright.
Joshua began research work under Assistant Professor Michael Hartman, and together they developed and built a Prompt Gamma Neutron Activation Analysis Facility, a spectrometer that uses the OSU nuclear reactor as a source of neutrons for unique analytical work.
Joshua’s building of this machine received an OSU award; and Joshua, still mentored by Hartman, began collaborations in its use with the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory in Richland, WA, and the National Bureau of Standards in Washington, D.C. Joshua now requires about one more year of work with this spectrometer to complete his PhD work.
Bethany, on the basis of her outstanding undergraduate record, received an excellent OSU fellowship. She, too, wanted to do her PhD work under Hartman, who had directed her first experiences in research as she carried out calculations for the OSU reactor refueling project.
Professor Todd Palmer, however, told Bethany that it would not look good for her and her brother to have the same advisor and also that he would give her a mathematical calculation problem that could be used for both her MS and PhD degrees, so she could finish her PhD more quickly. He also repeatedly told her that she was his best student. Since Bethany likes and is very skilled in mathematical work and she wanted to complete her PhD as soon as possible, she accepted Palmer’s offer.
When Matthew arrived later, he began research work under Professor Jack Higginbotham, who, in addition to being a 24-year veteran of the OSU faculty, is President of the OSU Faculty Senate and director of the Oregon Space Grant Consortium, a large OSU NASA program. Matthew’s research under Professor Higginbotham involves conceptual and design work involving the use of nuclear propulsion for unmanned exploration vehicles in far outer space.
Preparing for Attack
Unknown to Joshua, Bethany, Matthew, and Professor Higginbotham, however, their idyllic situation at OSU was soon to become instead an unprecedented academic nightmare.
The first sign of trouble brushed gently against Joshua one afternoon when he was walking through the entryway of the department radiation center. As he passed, a man who had been looking over the student photos on the front hall wall said to the secretary, “I understand that Art Robinson has kids in this department.” She replied, “Why yes, there is Joshua Robinson now.” Joshua smiled, but the man returned his smile instead with an unfriendly stare and then stalked out of the building.
More seriously, even though Bethany was doing excellent work for Palmer, he was directing her research work down many dead ends. He was also giving her many substantial things to do that, contrary to ordinary academic practice, he said could not be included in her graduate thesis. Moreover, he also used her to do many personal chores for him.
Palmer was also in the process of divorcing his wife, who is a faculty member of another OSU department, and then marrying medical physics Assistant Professor Camille Lodwick. Bethany attributed the difficulties to Palmer’s personal troubles and just worked harder. Later, Palmer and Lodwick purchased the Bombs Away Café and Bar across the street from OSU, which caused an additional distraction.
At one point, Palmer’s misdirection halted the work for 8 months, and Bethany became very concerned. Contrary to their agreement, Palmer, who is a long time associate of department chairwoman Kathryn Higley, was not allowing Bethany to write up her ongoing work as an MS thesis, which would permit Bethany to take her PhD qualifying exams.
On several occasions, as the months and then years passed, Palmer promised to do this, but then each time broke his promise. Bethany’s solution was to just keep working and let her work speak for itself. Yet, time dragged on, while Palmer completely broke the promises he had originally made to Bethany.
In addition, the Robinsons are conservative, Christian, homeschooled students. They are a close-knit family who work together in many ways. Some members of the OSU faculty value this background, but it is quite different from that favored by many other OSU faculty and administrators. So while most people were apparently friendly to the Robinsons, some viewed them differently.
While these developments were disappointing, the students’ prospects still seemed bright. The arrival of Joshua and his wife Fama’s third little boy, and Matthew’s admission to OSU and his subsequent 3.91 GPA buoyed everyone’s spirits.
The “Sins” of the Father
There was, however, a large looming shadow over these three students in the person of their father, Art Robinson. Art deliberately had essentially no contact with OSU during these years, in order to avoid any inference that he was involved in their educations, but his professional activities elsewhere were inadvertently creating a very serious problem for Joshua, Bethany, and Matthew.
Dwarfing these earlier controversial activities, Art and his family decided to oppose 12-term incumbent Democrat Peter DeFazio, who is very popular among OSU faculty and administrators, in the Oregon District 4 Congressional campaign in 2010. Art garnered 44% of the vote in this first try, including majority votes in the rural counties of District 4, and came closer to defeating DeFazio than anyone else had in previous elections. Art has announced that he will run for this congressional position again in 2012.
During the campaign, Phil Mote in the atmospheric sciences division used the OSU email system to lobby against Art; David Hamby and Kathryn Higley had DeFazio in for a VIP visit to the nuclear engineering department (even though DeFazio is a virulent opponent of nuclear energy);
and OSU President Ray staged a publicized visit on the campus with DeFazio shortly before the election and refused to meet with Robinson. This is perhaps unsurprising, since DeFazio and the other Oregon Democrat congressmen sent a reported $27 million in earmarked funding to OSU during the last legislative cycle, and Robinson opposes all earmark funding.
The university is not supposed to be used for the purpose of supporting political candidates, but Robinson ignored OSU’s obvious support for DeFazio. He simply stayed away from OSU and campaigned in the surrounding county. Most OSU employees and many students live in District 4, although OSU itself is not in the district.
Nevertheless, politics is politics, and in his desperation to keep his congressional seat, DeFazio, in a million dollar media blitz, painted Art as a nutcase who planned to promote racism, put radioactive waste in Oregon drinking water, end social security payments, close the public schools, help Wall Street destroy Oregon jobs, and end all taxation of energy company executives—an unscrupulous agitator who takes campaign funds from money launderers and drug dealers, and lives in a “survivalist compound” on social security.
While these ridiculous claims proved mostly a source of amusement to well-informed voters, they didn’t improve Art Robinson’s already diminished image on the OSU campus.
Yet, Art’s reputation and the antics of his opponent should not have affected the academic situation of Joshua, Bethany, and Matthew, whose course work, examination, and research performance in their PhD programs was exemplary. Unfortunately, they apparently did.
It is very likely that, had Art not run against DeFazio and then announced that he would run against him again, the Robinson students would all eventually have received PhD degrees in nuclear engineering from OSU without unusual difficulty.
Retribution Overdrive: Punishing Joshua Robinson and Professor Higginbotham
Immediately after the November 2 election results were known, actions were taken to prevent the Robinson students from receiving PhD degrees from OSU regardless of their academic, examination, and research performance.
The first moves involved a written and then oral PhD qualifying examination to be taken by Joshua Robinson. Professor David Hamby, a former Corvallis City Council member who made no secret of his strong political opposition to Art Robinson, took control of the written examination, even though OSU catalogue rules precluded him from doing so. Hamby then improperly rigged the examination process.
Nevertheless, Joshua scored a conditional pass on the written exam, requiring an oral exam to clear the condition. When an attempt to prevent the oral exam failed, Hamby and Kathryn Higley then attempted to rig the oral exam by changing the composition of the exam committee—removing nuclear engineer Jack Higginbotham and replacing him with health physics Assistant Professor Abi Farsoni, a former Hamby student who is in the unfortunate position that he depends upon Hamby for all aspects of his professional status.
This too failed. Joshua ultimately easily passed the oral exam.
The exam rigging did, however, cause an explosion in the Department of Nuclear Engineering and Radiation Health Physics. Privy to not only these actions but other shenanigans directed toward the Robinson students, Professor Jack Higginbotham, with 24 years of experience at OSU, had seen enough.
First, he complained to Kathryn Higley, who responded by ordering him not to speak to Art Robinson. Ignoring her orders, Professor Higginbotham told Joshua and then Art Robinson details of the maneuvers by a few faculty administrators within the department, which were intended to see that Joshua and then Bethany never received PhDs from OSU, with Matthew likely to follow.
The result was an immediate attack by these same people on Professor Higginbotham whose career now hangs by a thread, regardless of the fact that he has been a distinguished member of the OSU faculty for 24 years, is President of the OSU Faculty Senate, and is director of a large NASA program at OSU. Professor Higginbotham has personally hired attorneys to protect his salary and save as much as possible of his career. This attack was solely the result of Professor Higginbotham’s efforts to help the Robinson students.
Subject since then to unethical persecution—from a Star Chamber humiliation before the department faculty to an ongoing effort to fire him from the department—Professor Higginbotham has not wavered from his principled actions on behalf of the Robinson students and has put his entire career at risk as a result.
Meanwhile, Professor Higley and her husband, Instructor Reese, moved on to a new scheme intended to prevent Joshua from finishing his PhD work. Joshua’s mentor was Assistant Professor Michael Hartman, under whose direction Joshua had built the neutron spectrometer now attached to the OSU nuclear reactor. When, however, Hartman moved to the University of Michigan, he continued to mentor Joshua, while Instructor Reese was listed as Joshua’s nominal OSU advisor in order to satisfy university rules.
Reese now issued orders, without Joshua’s knowledge, barring Joshua from access to the reactor bay in which his equipment is located. Appearing one day for work, Joshua was informed by the reactor control operator that he had orders not to permit Joshua to enter the room where his spectrometer is located. Those orders remain in effect today, so Joshua’s experimental work necessary to completing his PhD thesis has been stopped.
Instructor Reese also terminated Joshua’s funding, even though Reese had agreed to fund Joshua through the end of his PhD work in return for experiments that Joshua carried out for the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory. OSU was paid by PNNL for this work, which Joshua completed.
Reese’s wife, Professor Higley, in support of these actions and in her capacity as department chairperson, sent Joshua two letters ordering him to form an entirely new graduate committee and to propose an entirely new graduate research program, thus abandoning his previous three years of effort.
Moreover, when Joshua and Noah met with Instructor Reese, he informed them that he was bringing in two graduate students to take over Joshua’s apparatus and research work. In effect, Higley handed all of Joshua’s work in progress and his apparatus to her husband for his own professional use.
Meanwhile, a vicious campaign of defamation has been spread in the department falsely accusing Joshua of all sorts of things and even attempting to associate him with the perceived transgressions of his father as falsely painted by DeFazio, including the outrageous claim that Joshua is a racist.
Like Professor Higginbotham, Joshua is now represented by an attorney. While Joshua could easily win a lawsuit against OSU, that is not presently his goal. He came to OSU to earn a PhD, not to win a lawsuit. The attorney is attempting to convince OSU to stop these actions, which are obviously intended to prevent the award of Joshua’s PhD.
Meanwhile, even worse actions were taken against Bethany Robinson.
Immediately after the election, Bethany was informed by email by Professor Palmer that he was taking away the research project that she has worked on for more than three years. This would mean that Bethany would never receive a PhD from OSU, regardless of her almost five years of excellent work.
Palmer stated that he was taking this action because Bethany had worked on her dad’s political campaign instead of carrying out the calculation projects that he had given her to do.
In fact, Bethany had not only worked on those projects, but had completed every one of them. For this reason, she had worked very little on the campaign. Confronted by this, Professor Palmer backed off, but not for long.
Subsequently, he sent Bethany a sequence of three letters all containing a demand and deadlines. He threatened that, if she did not comply with the deadlines, he would withdraw as her advisor, leaving her with no graduate degree whatsoever and five years of lost efforts. Palmer made it clear, in several communications, that he would try to prevent her from using any of her work with him in a graduate thesis if he withdrew.
In these letters, Palmer demanded that she choose (before the deadline) between two alternatives—an ME degree based only on her course work, with no credit whatsoever for her research, or an MS degree based on all of her research and composed in such a way that none of that work would count toward a PhD.
If she wanted a PhD, she would need to essentially start over. He also advised her to drop the courses that she was then taking because those courses would only be of value to a PhD degree.
In these letters, Palmer also set a deadline for the submission of her MS thesis that was so short that it would be impossible for Bethany to comply, thereby forcing her to take an ME degree, which would automatically remove her from the graduate school.
Bethany, therefore, engaged the same attorney as Joshua, who replied to Palmer’s third emailed threat. As a consequence, Bethany is now in limbo, not taking her courses but still inching forward with her research in a highly demoralized state.
Bethany has been told by Palmer’s department faculty friends that if she does not comply with his demands, she will be dismissed from OSU with no graduate degree whatsoever. She also has been told that Joshua is to be dismissed, so that there is certainly no hope for her in resistance.
It is not surprising that this talented, hardworking student who formerly was on track to become a PhD in nuclear engineering is confused and emotionally exhausted. Her family is alarmed and very worried about her. Palmer’s goal has been to demoralize Bethany and, by means of threats, to force her to give up her dream of a PhD—a graduate degree that she has nearly earned.
Taking Action—And Losing
After Professor Higginbotham’s warning in early December, Art Robinson abandoned his previous policy of noninvolvement in his children’s educations at OSU and worked to advise them and to act within OSU and out of public view in an effort to stop these unprincipled actions.
Two weeks before the end of the winter term, however, Art learned conclusively that his efforts had failed:
- Instructor Reese told Joshua and Noah that he was bringing in two other students to take over Joshua’s apparatus and research.
- Dr. Hartman, who had been wonderfully supportive of Joshua throughout this ordeal, had—after visiting the department and presumably speaking with Hamby, Higley, and Reese—entirely changed his opinion and spoken to Joshua very pessimistically about his professional future.
- On a visit to Washington, D.C., Professor Higginbotham had been asked by officials in connection with the NASA program he directs there about the continuation of the program in view of his likely dismissal. To inform a scientist’s funding agency about such a possibility is very damaging to his relations with the agency, so this indicated that Professor Higginbotham’s dismissal was imminent as well.
There was only one defensive action that Art Robinson could still take. He could inform the public about these antics by public employees at OSU in the hopes that they would intervene.
Art met with Dean Adams at OSU and asked one final time that Hamby, Higley, Reese, and Palmer be required to cease their prejudicial actions and allow Professor Higginbotham, Joshua, Bethany, and Matthew (who was now at risk because Professor Higginbotham is his thesis professor) to resume their ordinary professional activities at OSU under the usual OSU rules and without extraordinary impediments. The Dean agreed to ask his superiors. He presumably did this, but to no avail.
So Art wrote a summary article about this affair, which was published on the Internet. He then sent links to the article to his email list. The result has been thousands of public inquiries to OSU, inquiries to OSU by many responsible organizations, and efforts by OSU alumni to induce OSU officials to act. So far, all of these efforts have been stonewalled by OSU President Ray and the people who work for him.
One alumni group has even offered fellowships to the three students to complete their PhDs and has also offered to pay all legal costs involved in a meeting between OSU attorneys, Professor Higginbotham’s attorneys, and Joshua and Bethany’s attorneys to negotiate an end to this problem. These alumni have also been stonewalled, with no response from President Ray, Professor Higley, or other OSU officials.
There has been no abatement of the unprincipled actions against Joshua, Bethany, and Professor Higginbotham at OSU. As things currently stand, regardless of the best efforts of many people, the Robinson students are unable to complete their PhD work and Professor Higginbotham’s career is on the verge of ruin—solely because he took action to try to save these students and risked his own career in the process.
About the Robinsons
In 1980, scientists Art and Laurelee Robinson moved their growing family to southern Oregon and, with the help of their colleagues, including Nobel Laureate Bruce Merrifield and Martin Kamen, the discoverer of carbon 14, established the Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine.
This Institute today carries out research in physical chemistry, biochemistry, and medicine in continuation of the work that Art (a graduate of Caltech) and Laurelee (a graduate of Seattle Pacific University) did together over a 17-year period, during which Art served on the faculty of the University of California at San Diego; as President and Research director of the Linus Pauling Institute, which Robinson and Pauling cofounded in 1973; and as President of their new Oregon Institute.
In 1988, however, Laurelee Robinson died at the age of 43 when their six children Zachary, Noah, Arynne, Joshua, Bethany, and Matthew were ages 12, 10, 8, 6, 6 years and 18 months old, respectively. Nevertheless, in the subsequent years and with the help of many colleagues and friends, this conservative, homeschooled, Christian family thrived, and the Institute continued its work.
Art Robinson is best known in science for his pioneering biochemical research work on the amide molecular clocks that are built into almost all protein molecules—work that has been brilliantly extended by his son Noah Robinson. In addition, Art is known for originating and carrying out much of the original work in the field of metabolic profiling, which is now a large part of the discipline known as “metabolomics.” This work involves the quantitative measurement of human health and disease by means of the quantitative analysis of biochemical patterns that are imprinted in the amounts of thousands of metabolic substances that can be measured in human breath, blood, urine, and tissues.
In addition to their scientific research, the Robinson family is today known for their work on American civil defense; their Robinson home school curriculum, which is used by about 60,000 homeschooled students in the U.S; their publication of more than 100 children’s books; their publication of more than 400 recorded performances of the great gospel singer George Beverly Shea; and their publication of the newsletter Access to Energy—a publication that they inherited 19 years ago from scientist Petr Beckman, who founded it 39 years ago. Access to Energy was founded on free market principles, and has been one of the foremost advocates of free enterprise and of nuclear energy for 39 years.
During their university years, the Robinson children excelled in science, with five of them earning BS degrees in chemistry and one in mathematics, and three of those degrees being earned in only two years. Subsequently, Zachary and Arynne earned doctorates in veterinary medicine at Iowa State University, and Noah earned a PhD in chemistry from Caltech.